Waiting and observing before committing to R is wise. He's made some promising choices. But as BTB pointed out - this isn't his first appearance at the infidelity rodeo. Fool me once shame on you, fool me twice..... and all that. And, y'all have been down the MC, church counseling, marriage retreats, infidelity book reading, "save the marriage" rabbit hole before. He's well versed on exactly what he needs to do! But he betrayed again anyway. IC for him alone is the newest twist. Let's hope he's doing IC for HIMSELF, that his heart is in it 'cause he might benefit from IC whether you go or stay.
Reminder = Only repeated, observable trustworthy actions and consistent commitment to healing and transparency demonstrated over TIME will show if he's worthy of even attempting R. Agree - three months is way too soon to initiate R - especially with a repeat offender. So don't let your guard down too soon!
Wondering about transparency in this NEW era of your evolving relationship. You mention he's sharing his phone location and access to phone logs. That doesn't feel like much - not exactly an exemplary transparency effort in the aftermath of infidelity! Don't want to assume anything - maybe you're okay with minimal transparency, or maybe you and he already share information on certain things so you didn't mention those things in the OP. Or is there a power differential in the relationship where he controls the information, or where he feels entitled to "privacy"?
InMyExperience, complete transparency was absolutely necessary to begin rebuilding (and to calm my hyper-vigilance), and that transparency included access to EVERYTHING. How else could I observe trustworthy actions, and how else could we create a NEW marriage based on mutual openness and shared responsibility? After the trauma of infidelity, he had to rethink what privacy looks like. Privacy and secrecy are two different concepts, but cheaters often invoke their "sacred right to privacy" to protect their secrecy. Or use DARVO around privacy to guilt the BS into backing off "If you can't trust me without checking up on me what's the point?" etc. We had to hash this out and make sure he understood the difference, and that he understood info access was all about helping me feel safe, not me controlling him. ETA: And why his definition of privacy was a moot point in our Marriage Mark II if he wanted to stay.
If your H is committed to healing and rebuilding, he should understand that sharing ALL access so information remains mutual, open and above board is super important to build trust; to recreate the marriage. Guessing if you do attempt R, you don't want that old marriage back :-). And equal access to info shared with an open heart is key to helping your healing! Your H is now sharing his phone location which is a start....
What about sharing his PHONE? Do you have the passcode and does he encourage you to go through his phone without asking first? Maybe I'm missing something, but access to phone logs through the phone carrier doesn't cover App usage like WhatsApp, email, note sharing (I've heard of people using Google Docs to secretly communicate)...... or how he's using his phone (maps, photos, browsing, porn, contacts, buying stuff and on and on). There's a gazillion ways to use a phone as a secrecy tool or to communicate on a phone besides simple phone calls!
Is he on social media? If so, seems you should have access to that - ETA: including DMs. After the betrayal my H deleted all his social media (his choice) and hasn't been back on since.
What about Email? Laptop or iPad? Sharing his calendar? ETA: Bridge/Hwy toll device billing records?
Credit, checking and savings, venmo type accounts, online home shopping accounts - do you have access? Do you share finances or is his money HIS money? You're married so 1/2 the $$ is YOUR money - by law. Don't neglect tackling the tough subject of how finances are shared (or not) in the marriage as part of the relationship reckoning initiated by his lying and cheating. Taking care of yourself (and the kids!) after infidelity must include financial self-care.
Look, no one wants to play marriage cop forever, nor should they. Whether the outcome is D OR R gotta eventually let go of that hyper-vigilance or you can make yourself sick, mentally and physically. But..... You're in the "gathering data" phase Sisoon mentioned. Not sure if you're truly able to gather data or truly able to accurately observe (or heal/recreate the marriage) if you don't have equal access to all information.
Yes, in today's high tech reality there are myriad ways a motivated cheater could keep secrets. Or keeping secrets could be low-tech and simple.... like hiding an old-school burner phone. Yet, seems seeds of doubt/mistrust and continued hyper-vigilance (and the possibility of more kept secrets) might fester if he's not 100% willing to be transparent with ALL tech/media/info at hand. And controlling which info you're allowed to see is, IMO, a huge flapping red flag.
Hoping the best for you Chica!
[This message edited by BoundaryBuilder at 9:58 PM, Wednesday, April 15th]